This is the November 2026 edition of our monthly series of Ethics case studies titled What Do You Think? This series is comprised of case studies from NSPE archives, involving both real and hypothetical matters submitted by engineers, public officials and members of the public.

Your peers and the NSPE Board of Ethical Review have reviewed the facts of the case as shown below. And, here are the results.

Your opinion has been registered for the November 2026 edition of our monthly series of Ethics case studies titled What Do You Think?

Your vote is recorded as:

It is ethical
Want to know how your peers voted? We’ll send you an email with the poll results on November 24.

Your opinion has been registered for the November 2026 edition of our monthly series of Ethics case studies titled What Do You Think?

Your vote is recorded as:

It is not ethical
Want to know how your peers voted? We’ll send you an email with the poll results on November 24.

A Review of the Facts

Engineer Doug is elected as the non-salaried chairman of the board of directors of an owners’ association of a 5000-acre subdivision in which he resides. The subdivision contains acre lots for the development of single condominium residences. The owners’ association employs a full-time manager and a number of employees who maintain the common areas and roads, provide security and perform other administrative tasks associated with the association. The board of directors are elected annually by the owners and are responsible for the operation of the subdivision. The manager and employees work under the direction of the board of directors and in accordance with the policies approved by the board. There is also a design review committee selected by the chairman of the board which is responsible for review and approval of all design and construction on all parcels and common areas.

Prior to serving as chairman, Engineer Doug was employed by the developer of the subdivision to design roads, water resources, flood control, etc. Engineer Doug now works for a related company which provides land development services to the owners’ association. Engineer Doug also provides design services to lot owners building residences on the parcels, and has indicated that he will continue to do so.

Was it unethical for Engineer Doug to serve as the chairman of the owners’ association and provide land development and design services in the manner described?

Applicable NSPE Code References:
Code II.2.b: Engineers shall not affix their signatures to any plans or documents dealing with subject matter in which they lack competence, nor to any plan or document not prepared under their direction and control.
Code II.4.a: Engineers shall disclose all known or potential conflicts of interest that could influence or appear to influence their judgment or the quality of their services.
Code II.4.d: Engineers in public service as members, advisors, or employees of a governmental or quasi-governmental body or department shall not participate in decisions with respect to services solicited or provided by them or their organizations in private or public engineering practice.
Code III.2.a: Engineers are encouraged to participate in civic affairs; career guidance for youths; and work for the advancement of the safety, health, and well-being of their community.

Discussion

Because of their technical knowledge, engineers are uniquely qualified to be of constructive service within their communities. As a result, engineers are frequently called upon to provide leadership in a whole range of affairs impacting the public health and safety. Not surprisingly, these activities are encouraged by the Code that implores engineers to seek opportunities to be of constructive service in civic affairs and work for the advancement of the safety, health and well-being of their communities.

In Case 84-6, involving an engineer serving as a candidate for the state legislature, we noted that participation in these activities must be tempered with a sense of reason and rationality as engineers are expected to act in such matters in a responsible and prudent manner.

Clearly, the Code requires a balance to be struck between the engineer’s involvement and participation in civic affairs and the need to refrain from such activities where the engineers involvement might be construed in a manner not befitting the engineering profession. This need for harmony is expressed in a number of the sections of the Code, see Code II.4.d. In fact, this section has been analyzed on several occasions by the Board.

In Case 82-4, an engineer, who was in full-time practice, was retained by a county as county engineer for a stipulated monthly fee. His duties included reviewing plats and construction drawings to determine whether they met county requirements, and made recommendations to local developers, county commissions, and planning and zoning boards. In addition, the engineer was retained by a city as city engineer for a stipulated annual fee. His duties included making recommendations to the city council concerning the approval of completed engineering work. The engineer had also been retained as a consultant by several private firms to help develop city and county project proposals. The Board found that it was ethical for the engineer to provide engineering services in his private capacity to the city, county, as well as to the public boards and commissions, but that it would be unethical for the engineer to provide approval or render judgment on behalf of the city and county or other public agencies relative to projects on which the engineer had furnished services through a private client.

It is clear that all of the cases heretofore involving Code II.4.d. of the Code of Ethics have related to situations where an engineer is performing activities in the area of public service and also in the private sphere. Under the facts of the instant case, however, the functions being performed by Engineer Doug are solely in the private sphere. The language in Code II.4.d. is unambiguous in expressing its intent to focus on the conduct of engineers working on behalf of government bodies.

However, we believe Code II.4.d. must be read in light of contemporary conditions and circumstances. Increasingly, within our society, as a result of changing living patterns and fiscal considerations, various governmental functions are being transferred to private groups or entities.

This trend was highlighted in Case 85-2 where a county hospital board delegated authority to a private health care provider to act in a quasi-public manner. We concluded that it was unethical for an engineer in private practice, who served on the board of directors of the private health care provider, to provide engineering and surveying services to the health care provider. As we noted, there has been a dramatic shift in recent years toward the innovative concept of “privatization” among state and local governments. In order to strive toward greater efficiency and economy, many local governments have delegated the responsibility for management and administration of certain services (e.g., trash collection, prisons, sewage treatment, hospitals, etc.) to private vendors with particular expertise in those areas. We noted that this development raised an interesting question: Is an engineer who is not in public service as a member, advisor, or employee of a governmental body or department, but is “acting for” a governmental body in a “quasi-governmental capacity, covered under the language of Code II.4.d? We concluded that where an engineer is acting in a quasi-governmental capacity and performing certain functions that are normally performed by a public body, that engineer should be covered under that language.

Likewise, in the instant case, we believe that the same rule should apply. While Case 85-2 is somewhat different than the present case and while we concede that the present case does not involve the issue of privatization, we believe the rule should be extended to cover circumstances such as those present here. To do otherwise would permit engineers employed in the private sector to serve on quasi-governmental bodies and act in a manner which undermines the integrity of those bodies. For example, under the facts present here, as chairman of the board of directors of the owners’ association, Engineer Doug has the authority to select the members of the design review committee responsible for the review and approval of all design and construction on all parcels and common areas. At the same time, Engineer Doug works for a firm which provides land development services to the owners’ association and design services to owners of individual parcels of ]and. Engineer Doug’s activities as chairman of the board of directors will involve him directly with matters relating to determinations made by the design review committee concerning the designs developed by him and his firm. Therefore, Engineer Doug, as a member (chairman) of a governing body (board of directors) is participating in decisions with respect to professional services provided by his firm in private engineering practice.

Engineer Doug indicated that he will continue to provide services to the owners’ association and owners of residences. Had the facts suggested that Engineer Doug would refrain from providing those services, the Board would have reconsidered its conclusion.

The Ethical Review Board’s Conclusion

It is not ethical

It was unethical for Engineer Doug to serve as the chairman of the owners’ association and provide the land development and design services in the manner described.

BOARD OF ETHICAL REVIEW
F. Wendell Beard, P.E., Ernest C. James, P.E., Robert W. Jarvis, P.E., Lawrence E. Jones, P.E., James L. Polk, P.E., J. Kent Roberts, P.E., Alfred H. Samborn, P.E., chairman

Note – In regard to the question of application of the Code to corporations vis-a-vis real persons, business form or type should not negate nor influence conformance of individuals to the Code. The Code deals with professional services, which services must be performed by real persons. Real persons in turn establish and implement policies within business structures. The Code is clearly written to apply to the Engineer and it is incumbent on a member of NSPE to endeavor to live up to its provisions. This applies to all pertinent sections of the Code. This opinion is based on data submitted to the Board of Ethical Review and does not necessarily represent all of the pertinent facts when applied to a specific case. This opinion is for educational purposes only and should not be construed as expressing any opinion on the ethics of specific individuals. This opinion may be reprinted without further permission, provided that this statement is included before or after the text of the case.